Is Popeyes Mac and Cheese Worth the Hype? 2025 Review

Yes, Popeyes mac and cheese is worth trying. The Homestyle Mac & Cheese features a creamy, thick consistency with a golden-brown crust on top, setting it apart from typical fast-food sides. Priced between $2.79 and $3.99 depending on size and location, this side dish has become a popular alternative to the restaurant’s famous Cajun fries.

What Makes Popeyes Mac and Cheese Special

Popeyes Homestyle Mac & Cheese is made with butter, cream, and cheddar cheese, then oven-baked and topped with shredded cheddar to create a golden-brown crust. Unlike many fast-food mac and cheese options that come out soupy or runny, this version delivers a thicker, more substantial texture.

The dish uses elbow macaroni pasta coated in a rich cheese sauce. The preparation includes broiling for a minute or two, which creates that signature crispy cheese layer on top.

Price Breakdown for 2025

Popeyes mac and cheese pricing varies by location, but here’s what you can typically expect:

• Regular Size: $2.79 – $3.79
• Large Size: $3.99 – $5.39

Most locations price the regular serving around $3.79, making it competitively priced compared to other premium sides. The price reflects the quality of preparation, as each serving is baked in-restaurant rather than simply heated.

Nutritional Information

A regular serving contains approximately 280-310 calories with 18-22 grams of fat. Here’s the complete breakdown:

• Calories: 280-310
• Fat: 18-22g (Saturated: 8-13.5g)
• Sodium: 510-830mg
• Carbohydrates: 15-21g
• Protein: 8-11g

This makes it a moderately indulgent side dish, comparable to other fast-food mac and cheese offerings in terms of calorie content.

Taste and Texture Review

The cheddar cheese flavor is strong and well-rounded, with tender noodles coated in sauce throughout. The dish features a mild to moderately sharp cheese profile with cheddar as the most prominent taste.

The texture sets Popeyes apart from competitors. The golden-brown crust complements the rich, velvety cheesy noodles underneath. Unlike thinner, saucier versions at other chains, this mac and cheese maintains its structure without becoming runny.

Some customers note the flavor could be richer for certain tastes, but most praise the creaminess and texture. One reviewer gave it 9 out of 10, appreciating its authentic homemade quality.

How It Compares to Competitors

Popeyes vs. KFC Mac and Cheese

Popeyes offers sharper cheese flavor and slightly firmer pasta compared to KFC’s creamy, mild cheese sauce. KFC’s version is thinner and more saucy like stovetop mac and cheese, while Popeyes clearly aims for a baked style.

In taste tests, Popeyes mac and cheese ranks highly, described as tasting like a big southern-style hug in a bowl. The baked preparation gives it an edge over competitors who simply serve heated cheese sauce over pasta.

Popeyes vs. Chick-fil-A

Chick-fil-A’s version features a three-cheese blend (Parmesan, Cheddar, Romano) and is also baked in-restaurant for a crispy top layer, similar to Popeyes. Both offer superior quality compared to non-baked alternatives.

Best Menu Pairings

Popeyes mac and cheese complements various menu items:

Classic Chicken Combinations

• Signature fried chicken
• Spicy chicken tenders
• Spicy chicken sandwich

Seafood Options Pairs well with Popeyes shrimp and fish offerings for added creaminess against lighter proteins.

Standalone Side The dish can satisfy hunger on its own as a comfort food option.

Allergen and Dietary Information

Allergens Present: Contains milk (from cheese) and wheat (from pasta)

Gluten Content: Contains gluten from both wheat pasta and flour used in the cheese sauce roux

Vegetarian Status: Yes, this is a vegetarian-friendly option containing dairy but no meat products

Vegan Status: Not vegan due to butter, cream, and cheese

Spice Level: Not spicy – it’s a creamy, mild dish with rich cheese flavor

Availability and Ordering

Mac and cheese is a permanent menu item at most Popeyes locations, though availability may vary. You can order through:

• In-restaurant dining
• Drive-thru service
• Popeyes mobile app
• Third-party delivery services (Uber Eats, DoorDash, Grubhub)

Always verify pricing and availability with your local Popeyes, as menu items and prices can vary by region.

How to Make It at Home

Want to recreate Popeyes mac and cheese? The preparation time is approximately 15 minutes, baking time around 30 minutes, for a total of 45 minutes.

Basic Ingredients:

• 1 lb elbow macaroni pasta
• 2-3 cups shredded cheddar cheese
• 1 cup milk or cream
• 2 tbsp butter
• Seasonings (garlic powder, onion powder, salt, paprika)

Preparation Steps:

1. Boil pasta with salt for 8-10 minutes until al dente
2. Create cheese sauce with butter, milk, and cheese
3. Combine pasta with sauce
4. Transfer to baking dish and top with extra cheese
5. Bake at 375°F for 15-20 minutes until golden

Using room temperature dairy helps cheese melt more smoothly, and avoiding overbaking prevents the sauce from drying out.

The Verdict: Worth the Hype?

Unless you have an aversion to cheese, Popeyes Mac and Cheese is worth trying as an underrated hero of the menu. Fast food lovers are increasingly willing to replace Cajun Fries with mac and cheese, showing its growing popularity.

The combination of oven-baked preparation, quality ingredients, and reasonable pricing makes it stand out in the fast-food landscape. While it may not revolutionize your life, it delivers solid comfort food that tastes closer to homemade than typical drive-thru fare.

Best For: Those seeking creamy comfort food, vegetarians looking for satisfying sides, anyone wanting quality mac and cheese without cooking

Skip If: You prefer lighter, less indulgent sides or have dairy/gluten restrictions

FAQs